Source:

HarrisX

MLB Fans Back MLB Salary Cap and Floor Ahead of Labor Talks

November 19, 2026

A new HarrisX poll conducted on November 9-10, 2026 shows that, heading into upcoming labor negotiations, self-identified Major League Baseball fans are firmly behind a salary cap and floor for Major League Baseball. More than three-in-four fans (76%) support the cap and floor system now being discussed and just 14% oppose it.

The argument that carries the day is the need for competitive balance:seven-in-ten fans (70%) believe high-payroll teams spending too much is a bigger problem for MLB than low-payroll teams not spending enough. Most fans (71%) prefer the "even playing field" argument for a cap and floor over allowing unrestricted spending.

“Baseball fans have made their verdict clear: more than three-in-four back a salary cap and floor,” said Alex Braun, CSO of HarrisX. “Fans see this as an opportunity to address competitive balance issues across the league. As MLB and the players' union head into negotiations, this data shows the fan base believes big market teams have an unfair advantage, and a salary cap and floor would help level the playing field.”

 

Key Survey Findings

There is strong support for both a salary cap, and a salary cap and floor. More than three in four baseball fans (78%) support MLB implementing a salary cap similar to those in the NFL and NBA, versus 13% who oppose. Two-thirds of Americans overall support such a cap (66%). When respondents were told the proposal includes both a cap and a minimum spending floor, support holds steady: 76% of baseball fans and 65% of adults.

Baseball fans see a competitive balance problem, and they blame big spenders. Approximately two-thirds of fans (67%) say MLB has a competitive balance problem because large-market teams like the Dodgers and Yankees can spend more and acquire more star talent, and 63% of adults overall agree. Only 33%of baseball fans and 33% of adults prefer the competing argument that MLB does not have a competitive balance problem, and that two small market teams, the Brewers and Rays, just competed in the World Series.

  • By more than two-to-one, baseball fans say the bigger problem is high-payroll teams spending too much (70%) rather than low-payroll teams not spending enough (30%). Among adults, this is 69% to 31%.
  • More than three-in-four baseball fans (76%) agree that wealthier, big-market teams have an unfair advantage because they can spend more on players, and two-thirds (67%) agree that the same teams seem to perform best year after year.

Fans expect that a salary cap would have a positive impact on the league and competitive balance – an argument they align with much more than the idea that teams should be able to spend without limits. Presented with a forced choice, 71% of baseball fans say a salary cap and floor "helps ensure all teams are on an even playing field" since small-market teams are at a significant disadvantage today, while 29% say teams should be able to spend as much as they want. The split is identical among American adults overall (71% to 29%).

Fans expect that a salary cap would have a positive impact on the league and competitive balance. While they are less sure about what it means for their own team and experience, few expect harm: only 7% of fans believe a cap and floor would have a negative impact on any area tested.

  • A majority of fans (56%) say a cap and floor would have a positive impact on baseball as a whole (44% of adults). Results are almost identical for the impact of the salary cap and floor system on competitive balance (56% of baseball fans and 45% of adults say it would have a positive impact).
  • Among fans with a favorite team, 47% saya cap and floor would positively affect their team, while about one-third say it would not make a difference. On their own experience as an MLB fan, 44% of baseball fans believe it would have a positive impact, while 37% say a cap and floor would make no difference.

‍

Would you support or oppose MLB implementing a salary cap system, similar to other major sports leagues like the NFL and NBA, that places a cap on the amount of money a team can spend on its players?

Baseball fansU.S. adults
Support78%66%
Oppose13%12%
Not sure9%23%

The proposal being discussed in MLB right now is actually a salary cap and floor system, where there is both a cap on the amount of money a team can spend on its players and a minimum floor that teams must spend on players. Would you support or oppose MLB implementing a salary cap and floor system?

Baseball fansU.S. adults
Support76%65%
Oppose14%13%
Not sure9%22%

Which of the following comes closest to your view about competitive balance in MLB?

Baseball fansU.S. adults
MLB has a competitive balance problem, as teams in large markets like the Los Angeles Dodgers and New York Yankees are able to spend more money and acquire more star talent than teams in small markets.67%63%
MLB does not have a competitive balance problem. All teams are able to compete and two small market teams, the Milwaukee Brewers and Tampa Bay Rays, participated in the World Series just this season.33%37%

Which is the bigger problem for MLB right now?

Baseball fansU.S. adults
High payroll teams are spending too much on players, which gives them too much of an advantage over the rest of the league70%69%
Low payroll teams are not spending enough on players, and they are not trying hard enough to compete30%31%

Which of the following arguments about a salary cap and floor in MLB comes closest to your view?

Baseball fansU.S. adults
A salary cap and floor helps ensure all teams are on an even playing field, as under the current system small-market teams are at a significant disadvantage and cannot spend as much money on star players as large-market teams.71%71%
MLB teams should be able to spend as much as they want on their players without restrictions or limits from the league.29%29%

How much do you agree or disagree with each of the following statements some people have made about MLB? (% Agree)

Baseball fansU.S. adults
Wealthier, big market teams have an unfair advantage over smaller-market teams because they can spend more on players76%60%
MLB needs more competitive balance between teams so that they have an equal chance to compete69%54%
It feels like the same teams perform the best year after year67%50%

Would MLB moving to a salary cap and floor system have a positive or negative impact on the following, or would it not make a difference?

Baseball fansU.S. adults
PositiveNo differenceNegativePositiveNo differenceNegative
Baseball as a whole56%25%7%44%25%7%
Competitive balance, or the ability of all teams to have an equal chance to compete56%26%7%45%26%6%
Your favorite MLB team47%33%7%n/an/an/a
Your experience as an MLB fan44%37%7%n/an/an/a

‍

About the Poll

The HarrisX overnight poll was conducted online within the United States on November 9-10,2026, among a representative sample of 1,087 U.S. adults, including 615 baseball fans. Baseball fans are those who describe themselves as a huge, big, or casual fan of Major League Baseball. Results were weighted where necessary to align them with their actual proportions in the population. The margin of error is +/-3.0% among U.S. adults and +/-4.0% among baseball fans.

 

See the Full Findings here

Let's find the right solutions for you.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Washington DC
1808 I St NW,
Floor 5,
Washington DC 20006
United States

1808 I St NW,
Floor 5,
Washington DC 20006
United States

New York
Floor 63
One World Trade Center
New York, NY 10007
United States

Floor 66
One World Trade Center
New York, NY 10007
United States

London
3rd Floor, Blue Fin Building,
110 Southwark St,
London SE1 0SU,
United Kingdom

3rd Floor, Blue Fin Building,
110 Southwark St,
London SE1 0SU,
United Kingdom

Toronto
351 King Street East
Suite 600
M5A 0L6
Toronto, Ontario

351 King Street East
Suite 600
M5A 0L6
Toronto, Ontario

Melbourne
351 King Street East
Suite 600
M5A 0L6
Toronto, Ontario

1/38 Gipps Street,
Collingwood VIC 3066
Melbourne,
Australia

Singapore
351 King Street East
Suite 600
M5A 0L6
Toronto, Ontario

Solaris at One-North,
(North Tower)
1 Fusionopolis Walk,
Singapore, 138628